All stories by Wendy Caster on BroadwayStars

Monday, May 27, 2013

Requiem for Smash: Did It Have to Be That Bad? by Wendy Caster

Smash has had its supporters and detractors, but even its supporters never defended its quality. "Guilty pleasure," they said. "The show you love to hate." And it's not like there hasn't bee…

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 02:13PM[SHARE]
Monday, May 20, 2013

Macbeth by Wendy Caster

In his one-man Macbeth, the protean Alan Cumming orates, cries, hits his chest, yells, whispers, throws things, and tries to drown himself. What he doesn't do is define characters or tell a …

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 11:31PM[SHARE]
Friday, May 10, 2013

Nice Work If You Can Get It by Wendy Caster

I had no intention of seeing Nice Work If You Can Get It. I'm not a Matthew Broderick fan, and word-of-mouth made the show sound lame. Then nicely discounted tickets became available, and Je…

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 01:58PM[SHARE]

The Girl I Left Behind Me by Wendy Caster

Jessica Walker has a pretty mezzo-soprano voice and a fascination with the male impersonators of the late 19th and early 20th century. With co-writer Neil Bartlett, she has turned these into…

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 01:28PM[SHARE]
Sunday, May 5, 2013

Honey Fist by Wendy Caster

It's amazing what really excellent playwrights can pull off. Take the Flux Theatre Ensemble's Honey Fist, by the wonderful August Schulenburg. In a dry description, it sounds like a stew of …

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 01:55PM[SHARE]
Saturday, May 4, 2013

The Call by Wendy Caster

When reading reviews, you sometimes just have to wonder, "Did we see the same play?" The Call, written by Tanya Barfield, directed by Leigh Silverman, and currently playing at Playwrights Ho…

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 02:36PM[SHARE]

Song of Norway by Wendy Caster

Okay, Collegiate Chorale, you spoiled us with The Mikado, and raised the bar far too high. Then along comes Song of Norway, an okay presentation of an unimpressive show. It doesn't help that…

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 01:52PM[SHARE]
Wednesday, May 1, 2013

Sans Merci by Wendy Caster

In Sans Merci, written by Johnna Adams and directed by Heather Cohn, two young women, Kelly (the awkwardly, impressively real Rachael Hip-Flores) and Tracy (the lovely and intense Alisha Spi…

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 12:10AM[SHARE]
Friday, April 26, 2013

The Drawer Boy by Wendy Caster

At the beginning of Michael Healey's play, The Drawer Boy, a young actor/director named Miles (Alex Fast) shows up uninvited at the door of a farmhouse, hoping to carry out research on farm…

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 01:44AM[SHARE]
Tuesday, April 23, 2013

Richard III: Born With Teeth by Wendy Caster

The Epic Theatre's version of Shakespeare's Richard III (here called Richard III: Born With Teeth) aims for immediacy, edge, and individuality, and it largely succeeds. With a strong cast le…

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 12:00AM[SHARE]
Sunday, April 21, 2013

Dance of Death by Wendy Caster

Thrilled to have an audience, George and Martha--no, woops, Edgar and Alice--strut their hated and acid barbs with the eagerness of a three-year-old saying, "Mommy, did you see that? Mommy, …

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 12:20PM[SHARE]
Tuesday, April 16, 2013

Collapse by Wendy Caster

A woman is bent over the back of a couch; a man stands behind her; a sex act is about to take place. The man seems reluctant; the woman encourages him; their discussion is clearly meant to b…

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 09:00PM[SHARE]
Sunday, April 7, 2013

Finks by Wendy Caster

Playwright Joe Gilford's parents were Jack and Madeline Gilford, and Finks is his fictionalized account of how the "Red Scare" of the 1950s affected their lives and careers. Finks has all t…

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 06:56PM[SHARE]
Monday, March 18, 2013

Hands on a Hardbody by Wendy Caster

(I saw an early preview of Hands on a Hardbody, so take this review with the proverbial grain of salt.)A bunch of people stand around a pickup truck, each trying to win the vehicle by being …

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 10:56PM[SHARE]

The Lying Lesson by Wendy Caster

Whether you are a guest, a speaker, or a show, it's important not to overstay your welcome. As a 90-minute one act, The Lying Lesson might have come across as an entertaining little show. As…

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 10:28PM[SHARE]
Sunday, March 10, 2013

Kinky Boots by Wendy Caster

(I saw an early preview of Kinky Boots, so take everything I write with the proverbial grain of salt.)Kinky Boots is not a great show. I'm not even sure it's a good show. But it is an entert…

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 04:09PM[SHARE]
Sunday, March 3, 2013

Much Ado About Nothing by Wendy Caster

Here are the main reasons to see this lovely production of Much Ado About Nothing: Jonathan Cake as Benedick. Clear and smart direction by Arin Arbus. Jonathan Cake. Delightful scenery (Ricc…

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 09:00PM[SHARE]

Belleville by Wendy Caster

A woman carrying a yoga mat comes home, drops her coat on the floor, starts stretching. She is startled to hear a noise in the bedroom when she is ostensibly alone. Her fear turns to annoyan…

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 07:39PM[SHARE]
Friday, March 1, 2013

Katie Roche by Wendy Caster

Watching Teresa Deevy's engrossing 1936 drama Katie Roche made this contemporary woman extremely grateful to be a contemporary woman. Katie is a servant in a small town in Ireland in the 193…

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 01:55AM[SHARE]
Thursday, February 28, 2013

The Revisionist by Wendy Caster

Jesse Eisenberg's new play, The Revisionist, seems to be a predictable exploration of familiar territory: Uneasy young man, complete with cache of weed, visits much older female relative. …

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 08:00PM[SHARE]
Sunday, February 24, 2013

Old Hats by Wendy Caster

If you like Bill Irwin and David Shiner, you will like Old Hats. It has everything you could ask for: baggy pants, brilliant physical humor, sublime silliness, and the magical ability to wal…

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 08:33PM[SHARE]

Passion by Wendy Caster

John Doyle is where Sondheim musicals go to die. His Sweeney Todd, with its instrument-playing cast, fractured staging, and missing throat-slittings, wasn't Sweeney Todd, and his Company, wi…

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 08:29PM[SHARE]
Sunday, February 10, 2013

Bethany by Wendy Caster

Bethany begins with Charlie (Ken Marks), a third-rate motivational speaker, practicing his spiel in the mirror. "And I'll tell you one thing about [your] higher power," he says. "He wants yo…

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 11:10PM[SHARE]
Friday, February 8, 2013

Clive by Wendy Caster

Clive, written by Jonathan Marc based on Baal by Bertolt Brecht, and directed and starring Ethan Hawke, is yet another tale of a male artist so charismatic and tortured that people line up t…

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 09:48PM[SHARE]
Sunday, February 3, 2013

Fiorello! by Wendy Caster

Kate BaldwinFiorello!, the 1959 Pulitzer Prize-winning musical, requires a lead actor full of energy and charisma. In the current revival at Encores!, Danny Rutigliano, while likeable and ph…

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 02:15PM[SHARE]
Wednesday, January 30, 2013

All the Rage by Wendy Caster

In his one-man show, All the Rage (directed by Seth Barrish), playwright-performer Martin Moran shares his intimate exploration of the sometimes-thin lines between hatred and love, victimhoo…

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 08:00PM[SHARE]
Tuesday, January 22, 2013

Collision by Wendy Caster

A young man dances energetically in his dorm to the music his iPod feeds into his ears. Another young man sneaks into the room and puts up posters of Che and Kurt Cobain. The first young man…

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 08:02PM[SHARE]
Thursday, January 17, 2013

The Mystery of Edwin Drood by Wendy Caster

If silliness can be an art form--and I believe it can--then The Mystery of Edwin Drood is an artistic triumph. From the pre-show call-and-response to the audience-chosen denouement, this mus…

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 10:04PM[SHARE]

Parsons Dance by Wendy Caster

A screen filling the back wall of the stage springs to life with vibrant video footage of the Everglades and other South Florida parks. Voices speak of nature, honoring nature, the importanc…

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 04:00PM[SHARE]
Sunday, January 6, 2013

Ode to Anticipation by Wendy Caster

Vivien Leigh, Robert TaylorWaterloo BridgeWhen I was a kid, Sunday was one of the highlights of my week because it included the Sunday NY Times Arts and Leisure section, with its robust and …

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 12:15PM[SHARE]
Friday, January 4, 2013

Show Showdown's Most Read Stories of 2012 by Wendy Caster

In 2012, Show Showdown published 146 total posts. These twenty were the most read--or at least the most-clicked-on. I have tried to find a theme, but with no luck. Broadway, Off-Broadway, Of…

SOURCE: Show Showdown at 02:30PM[SHARE]

All that Chat