Just in time for the theatrical release of Wicked: For Good, Tony winner Darren Criss partnered with Third Reprise for an 80s-style pop-rock cover of "I'm Not That Girl," originally sung by Elphaba in Wicked. Watch as Criss reimagines the fan-favorite number, with help from background vocalists, guitar players, bass, drums, and percussion. Recorded at GB's Juke Joint in Queens, the video is directed by Isabel Weinber…
SOURCE: BroadwayWorld at 01:46PM on November 24, 2025